In the quiet town of Winston, Indiana, a cruel teenage prank leads to the death of a vulnerable boy—an act the town’s golden quarterback believes will stay buried forever. Years later, strange things begin appearing in the nearby lake: half-eaten fish, missing people, and signs of something monstrous lurking beneath the water’s surface. As corruption, blackmail, and powerful businessmen tighten their grip on the town, terrifying disappearances escalate—until a young woman is violently dragged from a boat and vanishes beneath the dark water. While investigators race to uncover the truth, a chilling realization spreads through Winston: the secrets of the past are coming back… and something hungry is enforcing justice. This year, the dead don’t stay buried—and in Winston, karma has teeth.